This series is hopefully going to answer some questions about eyeliner, and provide some tips to help you use it better. This first part is a brief history and a rundown of each type available.
The use of eyeliner started in Ancient Egypt as far back as 10,000 BC. Back then girls and guys lined their lids with kohl not only to look pretty and enhance their eye shape, but to protect their eyes from the glare of the sun. Ancient Egyptians used a mixture of ash, copper, lead, ochre, burnt almonds, and more to line their eyes, and applied it with a small pointed stick. Eyeliner has come a long way since then and now comes in many forms: liquid, pencil, kajal, gel, and cream.
Here’s a rundown of each type, what to look for, and what they’re good for:
Pencil Liner:

Pencil liners are the easiest to control and are the best type of liner for beginners. Just try to get one that’s as soft as possible, you don’t want to pull or scratch the sensitive skin around your eye. Also, because pencils tend to be softer in color, look for a very pigmented product, like Urban Decay’s 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencils (shown above), or Revlon Colorstay liners.
Pencil liners are best for softer, smudgier lines, and for lining your waterline.
Liquid Liner:

Liquid liners are my least favorite, just because I find them more time consuming than gel liners, which give the same result. Liquid liners usually come with one of two brush tips: a pointed brush (as shown above, Victoria’s Secret Glitter Liners) or a pointed sponge (like Revlon Colorstay Liquid Liner). I personally prefer the pointed brush because I find it offers more control and makes it easier to draw thin lines, but it’s all a matter of personal preferance. These products offer quite a bit of pigmentation and usually dry really quickly, so they’re good for creating dark, sharp lines. Because they are obviously liquid, these liners are a little more difficult to apply, so be sure to steady your hand while drawing the line. Try resting your hand on your cheek while applying liquid liner.
I wouldn’t recommend using a liquid liner in the waterline. Opt for a pencil liner instead.
Kajal:

Kajals are much like pencil liners in that they’re easy to use. They are very pigmented however, so you have to be a bit more precise with them. Also, a lot of kajals are produced outside North America and may not be FDA approved – some even contain lead, so make sure to do your research before purchasing. The Shahnaz Hussain Kajal, shown above, is safe and lead free. The L’Oreal HIP line also has a kajal liner.
Kajals can be used on the waterline (just be sure it’s a safe product!).
Gel/Cream Liner:

My favorite type of eyeliners are creams and gels. With a little practice and a good liner brush (either angled or pointed), you can create really nice precise lines. In my opinion, its also the easiest way to create winged liner (a little flick at the outer corner of the eye extending towards the brow). This type of liner is relatively new, but larger companies have recently hopped on the bandwagon and you can even find these little pots at the drugstore (check out L’Oreal HIP Color Truth Cream Liner, shown above). With cream/gel liners, look for a pigmented, creamy formula that goes on smooth and just practice!~
Gel and cream liners can be used in the waterline, but I still prefer to use a pencil.
Tip: For beginners, an easy way to get used to using eyeliner is to dip a damp liner brush into your favorite dark shadow and smudge it along your lash line. With powder shadow, it’s easier to fix mistakes and easier to apply.
—Next in this series: an eyeliner how-to—